HEALTH AND TRANSPARENCY: HOW COMPANIES USE DIETIANS TO SLYLY MANIPULATE
I have found myself exceptionally aware of the content that I absorb and pairing this with my newly heightened awareness of my food consumption, this article was a little more than fear-confirming. The real problem here is not just that dietitians are promoting products in their content, it’s that they aren’t OBVIOUSLY disclosing the fact that their content is a form of advertisement. Most of these dietitians are very slyly including information in the captions of their videos which, let’s be honest, is not the most consumed part of social media content.
A particularly interesting topic presented in the PBS article is the concept of “para-social relationships’. This is an idea that is presented in Groundswell, specifically chapter 10 titled “Tapping the Groundswell with Twitter ''. In this chapter, the story of mother Fadra Nally and her son, who is a big fan of McDonald's Happy Meal and the toys that come with them, is presented. Fadra regularly uses Twitter to share her life as a mother. After her son receives a toy in his Happy Meal that he doesn’t like, Fadra decides to post about it on social media. A representative from McDonald’s customer satisfaction department responds to her tweet and Fadra ends up receiving an action figure for her son. This is an example of how companies use social media to interact with their customers to improve customer satisfaction. This example of dietitians is a perfect example of para-social relationships because of the personable, casual nature of the interactions between social media consumers and large companies. This establishes connection and trust between the consumer and the company. In this example though, there is a third party: the dietitian. This bridges the gap between the company and the consumer even more than communicating directly between the two entities.
I think a lot of people are beginning, or have already begun, to evaluate their relationship with social media as there is serious toxicity within different social media environments. I think this is especially the case for the dietitian and diet culture “community” on social media sites like TikTok and Instagram. Shockingly, there is such a lack of transparency and this presents another debatable idea about how involved social media platforms should be in the fact-checking and monitoring of content as, especially as seen in this case, there are eminent risks.
Link to Article:
Another Interesting Resource:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/wellness/2023/09/13/dietitian-instagram-tiktok-paid-food-industry/



Hi Kaya,
ReplyDeleteThe discussion around food has always been one of debate for as long as I can remember. One of the aspects that I always find interesting is how much trust people rely on those they see on the internet with or without qualifications. It's also interesting how much of the nutrition industry is based around white bodies. Often I would hear from nutritionist in America about Mexican food being unhealthy despite a lot of our dishes being vegan and keto friendly.
The internet is full of manipulators and fraudsters who present themselves as experts in health, fitness, diet, medicine, and other fields. Some of these fraudsters use the internet to build a huge following to sell their products, launch books, or seek recognition. The problem is that many internet users believe information from unqualified experts, which leads to health problems, financial losses, and criminal activities. Since the fraudsters are relentless in their activities, actual scientists should also earnestly publish facts that help internet users form informed decisions that will not harm their lives. Failure to do so will leave the public vulnerable to misinformation by self-centered manipulators.
ReplyDelete